Performance Appraisal - Merit Pay - Pay For Performance and Employee Reviews Advice

Managers and human resource professionals often struggle with the linking of performance management and performance appraisal to performance pay or merit pay. It makes intuitive sense to reward the most valuable employees, but the practice is not a simple one, since it is common to create undesired and unanticipated side effects regardless of how you go about the task of using performance appraisals to determine raises. Here's some guidance, adapted from Performance Management - A Briefcase Book, by Robert Bacal (McGraw-Hill)

First, there is no "best" way to link pay or salary to employee performance, and no best way to implement merit pay. There is only a "best" way in your situation or company, and what works in one place may not be best in another. So, you need to decide based on what you want to create, your circumstances, and the culture of your company. However, here's an approach.

Acknowledge that no pay for performance system is perfect. Nor is there a perfect way of accurately assessing the value of employee contributions. So, is there a "best way"?

If you want to tie pay to performance, here's how to do it. You make it a part of the performance planning process. You establish the criteria for a pay increase when you set objectives and standards. So, at the beginning of the year, each employee should know what he or she needs to achieve in order to receive the pay increase or bonus. You don't tie pay to ratings or rankings. you make sure the criteria are as objective and measurable as possible to reduce arguments. And, finally, no surprises at the end of the year.

Also, take the position that it is your job (as the manager) to help each employee hit that target, make that extra money, or get the bonus. Make it clear that you'll do what's necessary to help every employee succeed.

In this way, you and the employee work together on the same team.

(c) 2007, Robert Bacal, Bacal & Associates. You are welcome to "reprint" this article online as long as it remains complete and unaltered (including the "about the author" info below) all links are made live, and this copyright notice and indication of authorship are included.

Bacal is a noted performance management author, consultant and trainer, and is the author of a number of books published by McGraw-Hill including Performance Management - A Briefcase Book, Manager's Guide to Performance Reviews and Perfect Phrases For Performance Reviews. For more free information and help with performance management, reviews, and appraisals, visit the Performance Management & Appraisal Help Center at http://performance-appraisals.org.

In addition to over 800 articles on performance related subjects, you will find tools to help with diagnosing performance, using progressive discipline, and setting objectives at http://performance-appraisals.org/learnto.

Employee Performance Evaluation - The Easy and Effective Way
When the time for employee performance evaluation comes around, it spells of a lot of work and stress. Many evaluations have to be prepared and more stressful is the part when your team member argues on what you have documented.There is an effective and easy way to do this if you can plan your activities towards this exercise. It will normally stre...

Creating an Effective Employee Performance Management System
If your employee performance management system is not effective in other words, your managers arent meeting their responsibility of getting their employee performance appraisals written, approved and delivered on time - heres the first question to ask: What happens to the manager who doesnt turn in all of his appraisals on time?Too often it turns ...

HR Needs It Signed on the Dotted Line
One reason HR has so many forms and other written documentation is because good HR processes are a company's main defense against employee lawsuits. I've been told by employment attorneys that any paper in an employee's file has little value unless the employee has signed it their signature is your proof that the employee has seen that piece of pa...

The Most Important Item To Measure With Your Elearning Management System
Organizations continue to struggle with how to gauge the business value of training. Research data shows a significant disconnect between what organizations view as the important and valuable areas to measure and what is actually being measured.What is usually measured?When you get deep into the research (Best Practices in Training Management, Ber...

Note that Employee’s Negative Behavior
Regular meetings with your employees give them and you the time together to discuss any issues that have arisen. But what do you do when your weekly meeting isn't changing the negative behavior of an employee?Break away from your regular meeting and schedule a meeting specifically to discuss the behavior (such as low output, improper processes, etc...

Are Your Strengths Under Control?
I first learned of this particular concept of strengths and excesses in the context of annual performance appraisals. Periodic performance feedback, coupled with an annual performance appraisal, is an integral part of a well-run business. Honest appraisals which inform the employee of his or her development needs are critical to helping the employe...

Benefits of Employee Incentive Programs
Businesses often use employee incentive programs to increase profit for the company. But it does not end there. Employee incentive programs also pave way for employees to exceed their current status of "just another hired employee". And because of this, an employee incentive program is a great tool to make your business work and your employees hap...